10 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes You Need Now

Hey there, beauty enthusiasts! If you’re on the hunt for the holy grail of mascaras but don’t want to break the bank, you’ve come to the right place. Today, I’m diving into the world of mascara dupes and spilling the tea on the ten best “Better Than Sex” mascara dupes you absolutely need in your makeup bag right now.

We all know that the cult-favorite “Better Than Sex” mascara promises dramatic volume, intense length, and lashes that could rival even the tiniest falsies by the end of the day. But let’s be real; not all of us can splurge on expensive products. That’s where these game-changing dupes come in. They deliver similar results sans the hefty price point.

From drugstore finds to high-end options at a fraction of the price, these mascara dupes are sure to make your eyes pop with voluminous lashes that look like false lashes. Whether you prefer a fiber brush, an hourglass-shaped wand, or a more traditional one, there’s a perfect mascara for everyone.

My Criteria for Choosing the Best Better Than Sex Dupes

There are so many mascara options in the market, and it can be hard to comb through the overwhelming choices to find the perfect dupe for the “Better Than Sex” mascara. Here’s a look at my criteria for finding the ideal dupe:

• Volume and Length: Who doesn’t love mascara that provides both volume and length? To make this list, I looked for mascaras with a rich, pigmented formula that coats each lash evenly, instantly adding volume without clumping.
• Smudge-proof and Long-lasting: A mascara is only as good as its staying power. The ideal dupe should be smudge-proof and long-lasting, ensuring that it stays put throughout the day without flaking or smudging. This is especially crucial for those with oily eyelids or for wearing mascara during hot and humid weather conditions.
• Easy Application: A good dupe should be user-friendly, allowing for easy and precise application. The mascara wand’s design is a crucial factor here, as it should be able to coat each lash effortlessly, reaching even the tiniest ones in the corners of the eyes. A well-designed wand also prevents clumping and ensures a smooth, even application.
• Lash Nourishment: While achieving a stunning lash look is essential, I also consider the mascara’s impact on the overall health of my lashes. The best dupes are those infused with nourishing ingredients that help condition and protect the lashes, promoting their strength and preventing breakage.
• Price and Accessibility: Now, one of the main reasons for seeking a dupe is to find an affordable alternative to a high-end product. Therefore, the price of the mascara is a critical factor in my selection process. Additionally, I prefer dupes that are readily available in stores or online, making them easily accessible whenever I need a replacement.

10 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes You Need Now

1. L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara

Known as the drugstore dupe for the cult status Better Than Sex mascara, L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara features an hourglass-shaped brush to deliver intense volume and make your eyes pop. It’s a top-rated dupe that won’t disappoint.

With this mascara, you can achieve instant volume and length without worrying about clumping. The formula is enriched with a floral oil, which not only conditions and softens your lashes but also ensures they remain flexible and not hard or crunchy. The effect lasts for up to an impressive 24 hours.

For variety, the mascara is available in four shades: Black, Blackest Black, Mystic Black, and Black Brown. If you’re a fan of waterproof mascaras, you can opt for the Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara for long-lasting wear.

2. Nyx Worth The Hype Volumizing Waterproof Mascara

Nyx Worth The Hype Mascara is a great option for those who love the too-faced mascara Better Than Sex Mascara but want a more affordable alternative. With its fiber brush and washable formula, it creates voluminous lashes without smudging throughout the day.

The buildable formula allows for easy layering, and typically, two coats are enough to achieve defined and fluffier lashes. The effectiveness may vary depending on individual lash length, but two to three coats generally provide perfection.

3. Essence Lash Princess Mascara

For an incredible dupe that rivals the original, Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is a must-try. Its wand shape and drier formula give a more pronounced hourglass shape and incredible lengthening power, all at an affordable price point.

The mascara is available in one shade, Black, and also comes in a waterproof version for those who prefer it.

One of the best features of this drugstore dupe is its affordability; it is so cheap that you can buy multiple tubes for the price of one Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara, making it an excellent budget-friendly option.

4. Maybelline Sky High Mascara

Maybelline Sky High Mascara has taken social media by storm and is often regarded as the near-perfect dupe for the cult favorite. Its wet formula and flexible wand deliver incredible length and volume for a false-lash effect.

The formula is infused with bamboo extract and fibers to create long, full lashes that stay lifted and never get weighed down. While providing length, the mascara also aims to lift and volumize from root to tip.

5. CoverGirl Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara

The CoverGirl Exhibitionist Uncensored Mascara is a drugstore mascara that provides dramatic volume and intense fullness to the lashes. It is infused with coconut and jojoba oils, adding nourishment and moisture to the lashes.

The mascara is available in the Extreme Black shade, which gives the lashes a jet-black appearance. The formula is long-wearing and doesn’t smudge, transfer, or clump, making it a fantastic drugstore option.

6. Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara

Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara is an excellent choice for those seeking elongated lashes. The formula creates unique “tubes” around each lash, resulting in separated, defined, and lengthened lashes. While it does offer a bit of volume and curl, its lengthening effect is particularly impressive.

The mascara’s thin, plastic wand is appreciated for its ability to coat lashes in hard-to-reach areas, including the inner corners. Users love the length it provides, its all-day staying power with no smudging, and how easily it can be removed at the end of the day. Overall, this mascara is a standout option for achieving beautiful, elongated lashes with a formula that lasts and is effortless to remove.

7. L’oreal Lash Paradise Mascara

Another gem from L’Oreal, their Lash Paradise Mascara, is an exact match for the Better Than Sex mascara. It’s a top-selling dupe with a similar pink tube, offering voluminous lashes and an intense black-brown hue.

This comes in four different shades: Black, Black Brown, Blackest Black, and Mystic Black, giving you some color options to choose from. The mascara’s tube closely resembles the Better Than Sex mascara tube. Although it lacks the hourglass shape, the soft wavy bristle brush of Lash Paradise holds a maximum formula for dramatic volumizing, catching every lash for a full fringe effect.

8. Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push-Up Lashes Mascara

If you’re looking for an incredible dupe with a high-end feel, Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk Push-Up Lashes Mascara won’t disappoint. Its thick formula and hourglass-shaped brush give you the perfect mascara for day wear or a night out.

One of the standout features of this mascara is its smudge-proof and humidity-proof formula, making it an excellent choice for travel or for those living in humid climates.

In addition to its impressive length, the mascara excels in giving the lashes a lifted and curled appearance. It is particularly beneficial for coating the inner lashes, even for individuals who find it challenging to lengthen the small lashes at their inner corners. The mascara’s application may not be entirely even for some users, which could be attributed to individual eye shapes, but this wasn’t a concern for everyone.

9. ILIA Beauty Limitless Lash Mascara

For makeup enthusiasts seeking a vegan, cruelty-free alternative to the cult-favorite, ILIA Beauty Limitless Lash Mascara delivers intense volume with the added benefits of organic Shea Butter and fortifying Arginine (keratin).

The mascara features a unique dual-sided wand with short bristles for curling and subtle volume and long bristles for lifting, lengthening, and separating the lashes.

I loved the defined look this mascara gave to my lashes, and I was particularly impressed by the ultra-black pigment, which remained easy to remove. However, there was a slight issue with smudging near the upper eyelid, so it’s worth considering if you’re prone to smudging.

10. Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara

Benefit Cosmetics is known for its high-end mascaras and the They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara is no exception. The wand features staggered bristles, allowing it to grip each lash effectively and separate them for a wide-eyed look. Additionally, the bristles on the tip of the brush aid in coating hard-to-reach areas, ensuring a full and even application.

The only drawback noted is that the mascara can be a bit challenging to remove. However, overall, Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara proves to be an excellent choice for achieving lengthened, voluminous lashes with the help of its impressive wand and formula.

To Wrap Up

And there you have it, the 10 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes that you need to cop ASAP. Who would have thought that we could find such incredible alternatives to the best-selling mascara at a fraction of the price? From the dramatic volume of L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara to the intense lengthening of Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, these dupes have blown us away with their near-perfect matches to the cult-favorite BTS mascara.

The best part is that these drugstore dupes offer a variety of formulas, from waterproof versions perfect for a night out to washable formulas ideal for day wear. Plus, they cater to sensitive eyes, making them an excellent option for all makeup enthusiasts.

I’m so excited for you to try out these incredible dupes! Need more makeup suggestions and reviews? Make sure to check out my 5 Must-Haves from the Sephora Beauty Insider Sale. Trust me; you don’t want to miss this.